Retention, Tenure and Promotion
On this page, you will find all relevant information related to Retention, Tenure and Promotion (RTP) for SJSU faculty.
- RTP Overview and Guidelines
- Periodic Evaluation of Faculty
- Assigned Time for Exceptional Levels of Service to Students
- Resources
RTP Overview and Guidelines
Pursuant to the CFA-CSU CBA and University Policies, all probationary faculty must undergo peer and administrative review of their record to attain tenureand all tenure-line faculty must undergo peer and administrative review to advance in rank, from assistant to associate and full professor.
Such review or RTP follows this schedule:
- Retention: In the third service year (or fourth if appointed with two years of probationary service credit).
- Tenure and Promotion: In the sixth probationary service year.
- Promotion to Full Professor: In the fifth year (or later) at Associate rank.
Early consideration for tenure and promotion is allowed. To apply for early tenure and promotion, probationary faculty must have already completed a retention review and shall not be scheduled for a special retention review.
If interested in early review, consult with your chair or director to determine whether there would be department support in the process. If they support your request, chairs or directors should send your name to FS to establish an early review case.
Materials to be Submitted for RTP
RTP performance reviews require the examination of a "full dossier," or extensive Working Personnel Action File (WPAF). Faculty account for their job performance and provide evidence for their claims.
Reviewers evaluated faculty accomplishments across the following categories:
- Academic assignment
- Service
- Research, scholarship and creative activity (aka RSCA).
Evidence for career achievements is entered in the faculty activities reporting area of eFaculty. See Part 6. of the RTP Dossier Format Guide to Using eFaculty for Evaluations for the official organizing schema and list of required and expected documentation. Entry of most dossier items is discretionary; faculty members determine the materials necessary to establish their unique cases.
However, some items are required due to standards related to professional responsibilities and recordkeeping. Such required items are either institutional records or faculty documents. Faculty are responsible for ensuring submission of all necessary dossier items. For assistance in obtaining institutional records, contact department staff, college office or FS (eFaculty@sjsu.edu).
Refer to Figure 1 in the RTP Performance Review Instructions for a detailed categorization of required RTP items. This document also features a graphical representation of the review process.
Departmental RTP Guidelines and Facts
Your department may have its own guidelines for RTP committee members and administrator reviewers, in accordance with the latest policies. These guidelines evaluate the same three criteria of academic assignment, service and RSCA as RTP in general.
The RTP process is designed so that reviewers outside the department can best understand faculty professional achievements. Departments may focus their guidelines on one or more of the three criteria and also offer guidelines per department subfield.
- Guidelines must offer at least two inclusive hypothetical sample faculty profiles for each level of achievement (baseline, good, or excellent) within a given category of achievement.
- Guidelines cannot expand or restrict the criteria and standards of University Policy S15-8. Where there are perceived conflicts with departmental guidelines, RTP reviewers must follow S15-8 over the guidelines.
- Departments may add to their guidelines other sorts of documentation that may demonstrate professional achievement ,and also estimate the resources necessary to attain each level of achievement.
- Guidelines expire after five years. Expired Departmental RTP Guidelines are catalogued below because they may still be effective for some faculty members.
- If guidelines expire during the candidate's period of review and are not renewed, revised or replaced, the candidate may include the old guidelines or no guidelines. If guidelines change during the candidate's review period, the candidate must indicate their choice of the old or the new guidelines. Only one set of guidelines may appear in the dossierand reviewers are restricted to considering only included, approved guidelines.
Note: Department guidelines must be approved by the Professional Standards Committee of the Academic Senate and the Provost. All faculty creating, revising or renewing Departmental RTP Guidelines must complete the Departmental RTP Guidelines Course.
Departmental RTP Guidelines by College
Using eFaculty for RTP
Dossiers are assembled and reviewed online via eFaculty, wherein faculty update their materials in the F180 area. This archive is open to faculty members at all times throughout the year.
To find assistance with building a strong case for reviewers, review the Center for Faculty Excellence and Teaching Innovation’s Retention, Tenure and Promotion page.
Periodic Evaluation of Temporary, Probationary and Tenured Faculty
All faculty undergo periodic evaluations to measure their progress and performance.
For Temporary Faculty
Lecturers, librarians and counselors (temporary faculty) undergo periodic evaluations during the spring semester:
- Annual evaluations cover the preceding calendar year (typically, spring and fall).
- Cumulative evaluations are required for initialand the renewal of, three-year appointments (“entitlements”).
The faculty collective bargaining agreement (Article 15) requires lecturer review as a condition of reappointment. Annual evaluations are conducted at least once per appointment periodand cumulative evaluations prior to three-year appointments, during the initial six-year eligibility period or recurring three-year eligibility period.
As with RTP, faculty are responsible for selecting the materials necessary for their
reviews. Failure to submit required documentation or otherwise cooperate in the evaluation
process
may be considered in a faculty member’s evaluations.
Full-time appointed faculty must always undergo department committee review. All faculty
cumulative evaluations must be reviewed by a department committee. Only part-time,
annual evaluations may skip department committee review.
All such evaluations are completed in eFaculty.
Annual Evaluations
Annual evaluations are required for:
- All full-time (1.0 FTEF) and part-time (less than 1.0 FTEF) temporary faculty who have been appointed for two or more semesters, but not holding a three (3) year appointment, must be evaluated each year.
- All full-time and part-time temporary faculty with three-year appointments are evaluated at least once during the three-year appointment term. As a best practice, they may be evaluated more frequently. If using a single annual evaluation, it should be scheduled in the second year of the three-year appointment.
Although not required, a temporary faculty member who has been appointed for only one semester or less may be evaluated at the discretion of the department chair or appropriate administrator. However, if a faculty member has served in the department in any prior semester (e.g., Fall Semester 2026)and is appointed in Spring Semester 2027, the faculty member is a two-semester appointee and must be evaluated on the prior semester's work.
Cumulative Evaluation
Cumulative evaluations are conducted to qualify lecturers, temporary librarian faculty and temporary counselors (but not coaches) for initial and renewed entitlements. Consideration for new or renewed entitlements can only be made after cumulative evaluation:
- Initial three-year appointments follow employment in the department for six consecutive years of service in the department (including the current year)and a "satisfactory" rating on a cumulative evaluation. The evaluation normally occurs in the spring semester of the sixth year. The period of review is the entire qualifying period, typically the current and prior five years.
- Renewal of three-year appointments follow three consecutive years of a three-year appointment and a "satisfactory" rating on a cumulative evaluation. The evaluation normally occurs in the spring semester of the 3rd year. The period of review for renewal is the entire three-year appointment time span. Note: Cumulative evaluations should be completed even if the faculty member was not appointed during the third (or any other) year of an entitlement.
- Pursuant to provisions of Article 15 of the CBA [pdf], the appropriate administrator must determine that the candidate performed the duties of the position in a "satisfactory" manner and has no documented serious conduct problems. Any faculty member not meeting this standard will be notified that they may not be appointed in the department in the future.
A cumulative evaluation may occur during the same cycle as an annual evaluation. At those times, cumulative evaluation materials shall appear simultaneously with those from annual evaluationand reviewers perform each evaluation as appropriate. The department or appropriate administrator may enter evidence for review. Copies of materials entered this way must be given to the faculty member before the first level of review begins.
Review Process
For instructions on the proper placement of specific materials into eFaculty, see eFaculty Temporary Faculty Training.
For more comprehensive review, faculty may submit additional documentation from the period of review, such as syllabi, course assignments, evaluations of non-teaching dutiesand official documentation of professional qualifications. Faculty with non-teaching assignments are responsible for providing documentation in those areas.
Range Elevation
Range elevation is the advancement of a lecturer or temporary librarian from one salary range to the next (e.g., L-A to L-B on the faculty salary schedule), accompanied by a raise of at least 5%. Advancement is granted after a review of professional performance by department faculty and administrators, resulting in a finding of professional growth and development appropriate to the lecturer's work assignment and the SJSU mission.
The period of review is the time since entry into the current range — since appointment or previous range elevation — or the prior six years of service in range. The range elevation application is submitted and reviewed in eFaculty. (See CBA 12.16 - 12.20, University Policies S21-2, F12-6 and S20-4 and SOTEs Interpretation Guide.)
Eligibility and Criteria
Lecturers and librarians are eligible to apply for range elevation if they have served at least 5 years in their current range in a single department or equivalent unit and have no more remaining eligibility for Service Salary Increases (SSIs). Range elevation requires that a lecturer or librarian demonstrate professional growth and development appropriate to their work assignment and the mission of the university during the period of review.
Accumulated teaching experience alone is not a criterion for range elevation. This is the only review type in which candidates' professional achievements shall also be evaluated.
Advancement at higher ranges (e.g., L-C to L-D) requires a higher level of professional growth and developmentand higher ratings of performance in the work assignment, than advancement at lower ranges (e.g., L-A to L-B). At a minimum, prior ratings of performance in the work assignment (in prior periodic evaluations) must meet the following thresholds:
- L-A to L-B: Sustained "satisfactory" performance
- L-B to L-C: Mostly "good" performance
- L-C to L-D: Mostly "excellent" performance
Application Process
To initiate your case, you must notify Faculty Services staff that you intend to apply using your SJSU email account. Please send a note stating your intent to apply by completing the Intent to Apply Form. Contact eFaculty@sjsu.edu for help.
Applications are only accepted via eFaculty.
Get More Help
- Email eFaculty@sjsu.edu or drop into an Open Lab for help with eFaculty
- Contact cfeti@sjsu.edu for help preparing your materials for quality review
For Probationary Faculty
All probationary faculty who have not undergone an RTP review during the fall semester of the current academic year undergo “mini review,” unless they are first year spring new hires, are on leave or are in the extended year of a presidentially approved extension of the probationary period.
Mini Review
The annual mini review is an assessment of a probationary faculty member’s progress toward earning tenure and promotion. These reviews are formative, providing the probationary faculty with review of the three categories of achievement in University Policy S15-8, so as to encourage professional growth that will merit the award of tenureand advancement in rank if applicable, by the end of the probationary period.
Periodic evaluations do not include voting on or stating levels of achievement (i.e. unsatisfactory, baseline, good, or excellent), or result in recommendations for retention, tenure, or promotion. However, if evaluators are concerned about progress to date, they may recommend that a candidate undergo a performance review (retention review) the following year.
Review Process
For Tenured Faculty
SJSU’s policy on post-tenure review is S97-5. It asserts that the purpose of the post-tenure review is to evaluate the professional effectiveness of the faculty member in terms of the scope and currency of their professional work, with reference to their current and future professional career plans. The review, to the extent possible, focuses on a positive, formativeand proactive approach to enhancing faculty careers.
Post-Tenure Review
If you put tables or otherwise complicated HTML into an accordion, you will be required to deconstruct it in order to launch your site.
Post-tenure review (PTR) is specified in the Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) Article 15.35: “For the purpose of maintaining and improving a tenured faculty unit employee’s effectiveness, tenured faculty unit employees shall be subject to periodic performance evaluations at intervals of no greater than five (5) years.”
This review is completed in eFaculty. All tenured, non-Faculty Early Retirement Program faculty members submit a post-tenure review in the spring semester of every fifth academic year in which they have not otherwise been subject to a periodic evaluation (i.e., PTR) or performance review (i.e., RTP). While still tenured, faculty in FERP status are no longer subject to PTR. Formal reviews of chairs and directors do not reset the 5-year PTR cycle, but such reviews may be used as evidence in PTR.
Administrators with the option to retreat with tenure are not subject to PTR. Upon retreat, however, they shall be scheduled for a PTR in the 5th academic year of return service, inclusive of the retreat AY if they retreated mid-year.
Faculty on an approved leave, sabbatical, or difference-in-pay leave during the PTR
semester may be scheduled for PTR the following year. Faculty scheduled for PTR who
have a compelling reason to delay their PTR may request a one-year PTR deferral from
Faculty Services.
Review Process
Assigned Time for Exceptional Levels of Service to Students
Assigned time for exceptional levels of service awards recognize support service to students that goes beyond the normal expectations of all faculty, such as:
- Student mentoring, advisingand outreach, especially as these activities support under-served, first-generation and/or underrepresented students and other practices in support of such students, including those caused by cultural taxation.
- The development and implementation of high-impact educational practices; curricular redesign intended to improve student access and success.
- Service to the department, college, university or community that goes significantly beyond the normal expectations of all faculty and that directly or indirectly is of benefit to students.
- Assignment to courses where increases to enrollment have demonstrably increased workload.
- Other extraordinary forms of service to students.
All Unit 3 faculty employees are eligible to apply.
Application Process
University Policy S15-1 establishes application and review procedures. All applications are collected annually in eFaculty. You may send your intent to apply to facultyservices@sjsu.edu.
Note: Prior awardees may submit their evaluation to their department chair with a copy sent to facultyservices@sjsu.edu.
Resources
Any and all RTP-related resources or documents are only available, and regularly-updated, on the Resources page.